- Nos tutelles
- Comment comprendre la sociologie ? A propos d'un livre récent - Persée
- Revue en ligne de sciences humaines et sociales
- From Figuration to Coordination: An Analysis of Social Interdependence Mechanisms
In , Michel Maffesoli became the teaching assistant of Julien Freund , a conservative political theorist and follower of Vilfredo Pareto , while he was lecturing in Strasbourg. Michel Maffesoli called to vote for Nicolas Sarkozy in the French presidential election of Michel Maffesoli is sometimes associated with freemasonry , although there is no way to prove that he ever was a member of it. Within the scientific community of French sociologists, the scientificity of Maffesoli's works is often questioned, especially since the furore concerning the thesis of Elizabeth Teissier "has created great controversy within the community [of French sociologists and beyond], and has led many sociologists to intervene in order to challenge the legitimacy".
- View of Introduction | Narrative Works.
- Non-luogo Apple (Italian Edition)?
- Michel Maffesoli.
- Der Erfolg ist in dir! (Dale Carnegie) (German Edition).
- All-American Kidd.
- Rheology and Fracture Mechanics of Foods.
- Führen: TaschenGuide (Haufe TaschenGuide) (German Edition)!
An opposition currently exists between Maffesoli's positions on "sensitive thinking" and supporters of a sociology embedded in the criteria of systematic and transparent scientificity. Other controversies have led to challenges to Maffesoli's institutional position: the scientific community protested against his appointment to the board of the CNRS and against his appointment at the Institut Universitaire de France.
On the other hand, Maffesoli's theories have been the subject of counter-inquiries, such as survey by Laurent Tessier on free parties in France and England. His influence can also be seen in various foreign journals. It is probably his book Le Temps des tribus , , translated into nine languages, which made his notoriety outside France; see urban tribes. Universities in Brazil, Korea and Italy request him for conferences. He has received a chair that was named after him in Brazil, and a honoris causa doctorate from the University of Bucharest.
His reception outside France is ambivalent.
In a article in the Sociological Review , sociologist David Evans concluded that Maffesoli's theories were not a positive sociological paradigm , criticising his work "incoherent" and "biased". One sociologist even stated that Maffesoli's sociology was a "sociology of club". The attribution of a doctorate to Teissier "created great controversy in the [scientific] community, and led many sociologists to intervene to challenge the legitimacy".
The thesis immediately aroused criticism in the field of French sociology, particularly that published by Le Monde by Christian Baudelot and Roger Establet on 17 April ,  and the petition of 30 April for the President of the Paris V University, and signed by social scientists. In an email of 23 April addressed to many sociologists, Michel Maffesoli acknowledged that the thesis included some "slippages". This controversy was sometimes caricatured as an opposition between positivism and phenomenology.
Comment comprendre la sociologie ? A propos d'un livre récent - Persée
However, criticism of Michel Maffesoli came from both research schools, though positivist critics received more publicity. Maffesoli's appointment to the board of Directors of the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique caused an outcry in the scientific community. In an email of 23 April addressed to many sociologists, Michel Maffesoli acknowledged that the thesis included some "slippages". This controversy was sometimes caricatured as an opposition between positivism and phenomenology.
Revue en ligne de sciences humaines et sociales
However, criticism of Michel Maffesoli came from both research schools, though positivist critics received more publicity. Maffesoli's appointment to the board of Directors of the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique caused an outcry in the scientific community. Ironically, and as an effect of the petition having two goals, it remains absolutely unclear whether the petitioners signed against Michel Maffesoli's appointment, or against the non-respect for parity.
In addition, in June and after the Teissier controversy, Michel Maffesoli himself proposed to delete the CNU, which he deemed "unnecessary". This decree was the subject of a controversy over the appointment of people not selected by juries from the institute, including Michel Maffesoli.
From Figuration to Coordination: An Analysis of Social Interdependence Mechanisms
Manuel Quinon and Arnaud Saint-Martin, two sociologists who were students of Michel Maffesoli in the early s, took inspiration from the Sokal hoax to demonstrate the lack of intellectual rigour in Maffesoli's work, as well as the absence of any serious peer review in one of the two journals that he directs. The article was deliberately incoherent and plastered with liberal quotes and references to Maffesoli and other postmodern thinkers, positing that in self-service cars in Paris, the signs of masculinity had been erased and corrected, in order to "give way to an oblong maternity - no longer the phallus and the seminal energy of the sports car, but the 'uterus welcoming shelter-to-Autolib'".
The authors of the hoax published an article explaining their aims and methods in March From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
- Privatization and Supply Chain Management: On the Effective Alignment of Purchasing and Supply after Privatization (Routledge Studies in Business Organizations and Networks)!
- Tiergem?lde (German Edition)!
- Variable Entlohnung oder hohe Entlohnung? Eine Analyse motivationaler Wirkungen (German Edition).
See also: List of scholarly publishing hoaxes. Renaissance d'une discipline , Rennes, Presses Universitaires de Rennes, , p. But more problematic than this patent inconsistency is Maffesoli's failure to be self-reflexive in a manner that might have helped him better understand how his own social and political position informs his reading of the "signs of the times" … Of course, the idea that one can, from the lofty perch afforded by the Sorbonne, capture and capitulate our "epoch" is on its face absurd.
Armchair sociology is not an unfair characterization of MaVesoli's approach to social analysis.
- A Woman for Women.
- What Management Does to Space Projects: The Franco-Soviet Project ARCAD 3 in the Late 1970s.
- Jean Carbonnier.
- Renaud CRESPIN.
- Introduction. Anthropologie et migrations : mises en perspective?